Ditra vs redgard. Both options have their pros and cons.
Ditra vs redgard This liquid waterproofing solution does more than keep water away, it also promotes tile adhesion and prevents cracking. It is similar to Wedi board in that you seal all seams with a urethane sealant. I am trying the new GoBoard right now. The Strata Mat is an ideal alternative to the heavy and difficult-to-install tile backer boards. If moisture is ever-present then you CAN NOT seal it in by covering it with any membrane. Therefore, if you’re wondering where this Dec 16, 2016 · Ditra or Kerdi knock-offs or other impervious substances (such as Hydroban or Redguard) theoretically should be treated like Ditra but we set tiles with modified over top of those substances. Also according to TCNA guidelines red guard is not required over durorock. I’m a project manager for a custom home builder. DITRA and DITRA-XL installations can be made waterproof with minimal effort. [More on those numbers in the Terms section] However, if you are installing Ditra then scroll down to the Schluter section below. Do you have a preference one way or the other? Most of the membranes are all similar. I'm cost estimating the big one and 1,300 sq ft of Ditra and All Set will set me back ~$3,500. Looking to install tile in our kitchen/dining room on a concrete slab. There are tons of different uncoupling membrane options available on the market, and people often seem confused between two popular options, RedGard uncoupling mat vs. These are both cheaper than using redguard. The time now is 04:18 PM. It sounds like this is already a waterproofing system so the redgard makes no sense anyway. Since the uncoupling function of DITRA is founded on its geometric flexibility to provide a forgiving shear plane, increasing the height of the product produces additional protection against stresses being transferred between the tile and After months of planning to find some Schluter Kerdi board and most likely pay out the ass, I came across GoBoard. Kerdi recommends using thinset to adhere their membrane to the foam pan (the Kerdi membrane also goes about 6" up the walls). Uncoupling membranes You also missed the preformed pan and schluter drain on the schluter example. Since the matting is made of waterproof polypropylene, the only extra step necessary is to seal the seams and floor/wall connections. 50 or 54" front to back, and 12 feet from side to side. Jan 13, 2021 · If you’re a good craftsman, and are able to slope a shower floor, frame your own niches, and generally produce tight work, what is the advantage to what seems to me like a very expensive and complicated system, vs just Hardi and RedGard? In the past when prepping floors I’ve always used 1/4” cement board, self leveler, or wet-set with mud. Is this needed? Rep at Floor and Decor said no, Rep at Lowe’s said yes. Which is the way to go? As I have to still get either one For those of you who have seen my last post, you'll know that I now am starting over with my tile shower! I found a tile contractor I like, and he is indifferent between cement board with Redgard or kerdiboard. I came across this product and saw it can be installed on concrete. Follow along in this video as I Sep 11, 2008 · 1. Is it as effective? I am a framing carpenter with a modest background doing tile work so would Schluter ® -DITRA and DITRA-XL are specifically designed for ceramic and stone tile installations. I know for the plywood to ditra… Hi all, I’m tiling my bathroom shower walls over go board (tub under) and penny round over concrete board for the bathroom floors. It’s on a crawl space with 3/4” plywood subfloor. After the comparison table, let’s consider the detailed differences from different aspects. This post compares: Cutting and installing Waterproofing The weight & handling of the products Costs of Ditra vs Durock Pricing 3 different installation scenarios 2 different comparison charts Let’s get to it! Estimated reading time: 14 minutes Jul 24, 2022 · RedGard, on the other hand, is a liquid waterproofing membrane made by Custom Building Products. The hearth will get warm, especially in front of the stove. The time now is 04:28 AM. Remember you'll probably need 2 coats of Redgard equaling a certain mil thickness per directions. Key Differences Between RedGard Uncoupling Mat And Ditra. The time now is 07:16 AM. 5GAL But which one is better: Strata Mat vs. We are leaning towards Ditra or Ditra XL, but should we consider Redguard instead, since we are concerned about height of the finished floor, to line up with adjoining carpet? Sponsored Links Crestone Tile 08-02-2009, 11:52 PM Hi Sharon, Feb 16, 2023 · Can DITRA Be Used on Walls? Even though Schluter mostly discusses the use of DITRA on floor applications, it can be used on walls. Jan 17, 2019 · Ditra provides uncoupling, whereas Redgard does not. It’s all just fun and games until your dog falls into the basement. Is that necessary? I can't find that much info online about this Why unmodified TS on Ditra and modified TS on Redgard? Tile Forum/Advice Board The FloorElf compares ProvaFlex tile underlayment with Schluter Ditra. Mine is also a steam shower though, so I was a little paranoid about gaps. My concern is that Ditra is plastic. I am ready to start tiling tub and shower surrounding walls. Based on an actual tile installation as well as deconstructing a piece of each in a side by side comparison. Never installed tile before on a floor. 2. Apr 28, 2013 · It takes two coats, properly installed, with RedGard to make things waterproof. I always thought mortar was installed directly on the slab, then the tike. Schluter; Price Comparison A distinct comparison between these two products is the cost. Feb 11, 2006 · Redgard vs Ditra Tile Forum/Advice BoardForum Jump User Control Panel Private Messages Subscriptions Who's Online Search Forums Forums Home Tile & Stone Forums Tile Forum/Advice Board Cleaning, Restoration and Sealing Reference Liberry :-) Professionals' Hangout The Mud Box Alumni Photo Album Other forums Buy/Sell/Trade Computer Training Fwict, for Redguard I'd estimate a roll of their seam tape and a bucket of the liquid membrane are the only things needed (plus drywall if compared to kerdi-board, of course), which would put it at ~$1/sqft. The schluter pan and drain are a large part of the cost of a schluter system. Mar 3, 2021 · Showers need waterproofing materials to be mold-free and for long lasting protection. I’ve heard of a lot of people loving the ditra but I see redgard makes a similar product. Oct 24, 2011 · Im doing two tub surrounds for a general contractor and the idiots greenboarded and put a knockdown texture on the walls soo i was wondering if i could just sand the walls a little and Redguard or Hydra ban the walls. Lol first off Schlüter invented uncoupling membrane. Do I need to apply a liquid waterproofing layer (redgard) on the cement boards before laying down the tiles with thinset? I would think that makes sense since ovbiously the cement boards Dobri Professionals' Hangout 9 03-06-2010 03:58 PM Basement shower concerns MelissaC Tile Forum/Advice Board 1 11-07-2008 10:51 AM RedGard® Waterproofing and Crack Prevention Membrane The #1 trusted and reliable liquid-applied waterproofing membrane for your go-to commercial and residential tile and stone applications. What are your favorite alternatives to redgard waterproofing membane? I mean there must be a better way right? Lets assume cement board application is neccesary (no ditra) We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Uncoupling membranes link to RedGard Uncoupling Mat Vs. Therefore, you don’t have to worry about the The FloorElf describes the effects of improperly installed Schluter Ditra membrane. Which is better? There are a lot of opinions but I’m going to try to stick to facts. Uncoupling membranes Oct 7, 2024 · He preferred hardiebacker with redguard and I already had a kerdi shower kit available, He will use the kerdi membrane over the shower corners and edges, and then the membrane over the ditra. . I know the concrete will eventually crack despite rebar, but hoping for a tile substrate to minimize the cracking risk. Further, the ease of installing Ditra has resulted in many contractors choosing Ditra vs cement board for their floors. That is a lot for a precautionary uncoupling membrane, though I'm definitely not willing to skip the step. Or, you can install a cement board over the plywood and proceed to tile installation. I have new tiles n such. Sep 10, 2022 · Cement board or Ditra. 12 American Most installation professionals understand what crack isolation, anti-fracture and uncoupling membranes are for, but confusion still reigns on what the differences are among the products. So you want kerdi. Jan 21, 2019 · Unfortunately, Kerdi is not worth the price in my opinion (I use Ditra on the floor but would rather use GB or CBU with RedGard on the walls) Why mixing the systems would make any difference if everything is sealed with liquid membrane? I’d just spend the money for the ditra. I still use the pre fab niches May 24, 2011 · Hi. Apr 30, 2023 · 7 Ditra installation tips such as how loose to mix your mortar, why your Ditra ends may be curling, and avoiding common installation problems Jan 16, 2016 · Since I de-railed the Kerdi board topic enough I started this one. Can you apply redguard over kerdi band? I want to install a Schluter niche but I don't want to use kerdi for the whole shower. The thing is, I noticed Ditra is not technically rated for crack isolation. Schluter KERDI and Ditra are excellent for this — learn why at Strictly Tile. This waffle pattern guarantees strong adhesion between the walls and DITRA. These are all reputable companies that make quality products and respect tile industry standards. Double check on steps Powder room floor transition backsplash tile questions Ditra vs Redgard for floors Exhaust fan location Ditra over Radiant Heat Mosaic Glass and Stainless on an exposed end Replacing a Plastic Shower Insert Shower Liner around Bench Corner BBQ Island questions remove Cement bed floor Aug 22, 2012 · Ahhhhhh, have you seen my signature line? :wink: I use and sell Ditra all the time, best thing since sliced bread, as they say! :laughing: Yes use Ditra instead of Redgard, it's much better. Yesterday I applied the RedGard Waterproofing membrane over Durock Cement boards. In the bathrooms I used Ditra mat with All Set; no issues at all and liked the project, but these rooms were ~80 square feet. I guess I am trying to figure out "why?" we use unmodified over Kerdi or Ditra but a knock-off product it is ok to use modified. I don't want to use the Ditra membrane product but rather tiles directly over the cement boards. Oct 8, 2022 · This post will examine Schluter Ditra and four Ditra competitors. Sep 20, 2016 · Examining whether decoupling membranes, such as Ditra, Redgard, and Stratamat, prevent cracked tile floors like crack isolation membranes do Mar 16, 2007 · Neither DITRA nor RedGard is the product to use on that substrate, you'll be back there standing good for another failure. I’m open to other products if you feel there is a superior easier to use product. Apr 10, 2012 · Hey guys and gals, Will be doing a bathroom gut and will be laying durock cement board over plywood sub floor. I used Sonneborne NP1. Mar 13, 2014 · Right, Redguard may help with expansion/contraction, but so does Ditra, so maybe Redguard is overkill (belt + suspenders) and I should just prime. Do you know what are the cracks in the slab from? Aug 27, 2022 · Ditra gets the last laugh as every other company now has an imitation alternative to Ditra for tile floors in their lineup. Ditra instructions are for modified for plywood or osb, but now that it is redgarded will it have trouble curing if i use modified? since the redgard has sealed the floor? Thanks for any advice, at this point i am prepared to pull up the subfloor and start over. 4; or 118. If you get down to a thin film of adhesive, and can see the concrete, using a high quality modified thin set should work well. Jun 9, 2022 · Schluter-Ditra vs. Then I did a heavy coat of Redgard on the floor. Nov 2, 2025 · I'm remodeling my bathroom and one of my contractor friends told me to redgard the subfloor before putting down ditra heat. Schluter is more expensive when comparing prices. I am remodeling my bathroom. 50" is the length of the joists and the depth of the room - it's a small entryway and adjacent 1/2 bath. Ditra: Key Differences And Features There are tons of different uncoupling membrane options available on the market, and people often seem confused between two popular options, RedGard uncoupling mat vs. I see Redgard is also widely used, but primarily for waterproofing. Normally i use hardiboard but i would rather not rip out the shiznit they Jul 31, 2022 · Mastic is not to be used over waterproofing membranes like Redgard or Kerdi Mastic over Ditra Schluter specifically prohibits using premixed tile adhesive over any of their uncoupling membranes like Ditra, Ditra-Heat, Ditra XL, and Ditra-Heat-Duo. Jan 20, 2024 · Forum Jump:Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest (s) Hello, I’ll be having an outdoor concrete slab poured and will be tiled with 12x24” porcelain tiles. When you look at the anchoring fleece on the bottom of DITRA, you will notice some square waffles which thinset lock into during installation. If it fails it is due to poor contact, improperly mixed thinset or two dry of thinset. Oct 26, 2009 · Subfloor questions and Redguard vs Ditra Tile Forum/Advice Board Apr 8, 2010 · Schluter Ditra Uncoupling and Waterproofing Membrane for Ceramic and Stone Tile Application - Quick Installation, Made of Polyethylene, 1/8-Inch Thickness, 54 Square Feet - DITRA5M - Carpet Underlayments - Amazon. That said, cement board is the more cost-effective option to consider, and will work just fine for most areas, especially if there isn’t too much moisture Nov 19, 2009 · Just wondering what everyones opinion on waterproofing tiled shower walls (w/ acrylic pan) was. Would like to use white grout, so I don't want to use gray thinset. Tile guys, give me your opinions on Kerdi-Schluter/Ditra vs Wedi for showers. It is a thin decoupling mat that offers a strong mechanical bond with adhesive mortar. Jun 22, 2011 · Moist concrete slab: Ditra, Laticrete, Redgard? - Ceramic Tile Advice Forums - John Bridge Ceramic Tile > > Feb 11, 2006 · Redgard vs Ditra Tile Forum/Advice BoardForum Jump User Control Panel Private Messages Subscriptions Who's Online Search Forums Forums Home Tile & Stone Forums Tile Forum/Advice Board Cleaning, Restoration and Sealing Reference Liberry :-) Professionals' Hangout The Mud Box Alumni Photo Album Other forums Buy/Sell/Trade Computer Training Feb 11, 2006 · Redgard vs Ditra Tile Forum/Advice BoardForum Jump User Control Panel Private Messages Subscriptions Who's Online Search Forums Forums Home Tile & Stone Forums Tile Forum/Advice Board Cleaning, Restoration and Sealing Reference Liberry :-) Professionals' Hangout The Mud Box Alumni Photo Album Other forums Buy/Sell/Trade Computer Training Jul 15, 2019 · I was able to use the Ditra shower tray, drain, etc for the shower. Now, to be useful, you'd have to waterproof up the walls, but then, what about the doorway? Most people find waterproofing a bathroom floor isn't a big deal and don't. You're less worried about waterproofing (Redguard), and more about uncoupling. Sep 19, 2010 · Forum Replies Last Post Subfloor questions and Redguard vs Ditra riverrat Tile Forum/Advice Board 25 10-26-2009 05:57 PM Ditra on concrete slab MARK3980 Tile Forum/Advice Board 24 11-19-2008 02:01 AM Ditra over concrete Bill Vincent Professionals' Hangout 22 09-29-2007 10:25 AM Warmly Yours and Ditra on Concrete BlueCanyon Tile Forum/Advice Sep 7, 2016 · Redguard uncoupling mat compared to ditra discussion on the TexAgs Home Improvement forum. More open time is good as I’m slow. Learn all about the 8 different methods to assembly tile or stone with Warmboard. For this small a floor space, is there a quality preference of going with Ditra vs Wonderboard/Redguard ? I’ll be using a relatively smaller format tile and the height factor for either approach is Feb 12, 2025 · RedGard: RedGard is a great substitute for people who are concerned about DITRA raising the floor height. Basement shower. Understanding the Purpose of Redgard RedGard is a waterproofing and crack-prevention membrane that is used on walls, floors, and other surfaces to protect against moisture penetration and mold growth. The slab will act like a big heat sink. Anyone with experience in this area with thoughts Modified or modified thinset for red guard? I understand the idea behind modified and unmodified. Yes that’s red guard over schluter. Check with the manufacturer about max temp for install. Warped floor. Installing guide for Tile or Stone over Warmboard radiant heat panel. 5 1,159 Subfloor Question - 12x24 Porcelain over Ditra mngsp 05-03-2013 05:22 PM by jadnashua 3 3,104 Please help us identify this tile brand 9000RPM 05-03-2013 05:17 PM by 9000RPM 3 1,320 Page 187 of 1327 « First < 87 137 177 185 186 187 188 189 197 237 287 687 1187 > Last » ad_forumdisplay_afterthreads     New posts Hot thread The choice between using DITRA or DITRA-XL depends on the nature of the particular project or application. Archives: Blog RedGard Uncoupling Mat Vs. Initial Mar 16, 2007 · Ditra will stop moisture and cracking but if you have standing water than you need to take care of that first. Quick Comparison Between Strata Mat And Ditra Check out this comparison table to briefly understand how Strata Mat differs from Schluter Ditra. If you are doing a bathroom, use REDGARD, if you are doing a huge space, use Ditra. Moved PermanentlyThe document has moved here. Apr 28, 2013 · All times are GMT -6. Uncoupling Tile has been successfully installed for thousands of years by incorporating an uncoupling layer, or forgiving shear interface, within the tile assembly. Moist concrete slab: Ditra, Laticrete, Redgard? - Ceramic Tile Advice Forums - John Bridge Ceramic Tile Page 1 of 2 1 2 > View First Unread Thread Tools Search this Thread Dec 10, 2024 · It wouldn't be my choice. Ditra cannot fail on a customers floor. I know it's optional by the manufacturer directions, but adding the 6" fabric reinforcing at the corners is never a bad idea. Ditra? Though both membranes have excellent quality, some noticeable differences exist between these two options—read out this post to learn them. For simplicity I was thinking of using Redgard (2 coats meets ANSI crack isolation membrane requirements) along with their thinset and grout for their system warranty. This could have been an EPIC FAILbut, I saved my shower by ripping out the Schluter Kerdi membrane and switching to the simple, roll on Redgard waterproofing. DITRA provides uncoupling through its open rib structure, which allows for in-plane movement that effectively neutralizes the differential movement stresses between the substrate and the tile, thus eliminating the major cause of Jun 22, 2025 · Can RedGard be used on Kerdi shower pans? Learn about the compatibility of RedGard and Kerdi, and explore the best practices for shower pan installation. Oct 5, 2023 · I originally planned to finish my shower floor with deck mud, shower pan liner, concrete mix, RedGard, mortar, and tile in this order: Pre-slope with deck mud Shower pan liner Post-slope with conc RedGard Uncoupling Mat Vs. 11; 118. Just trying to waterproof floor to prevent future mistakes. 2) We want to add a waterproof membrane for the non-shower part of the room as well, and join it to the curb of the wedi shower pan. May 19, 2022 · RedGard Vs. So What is the wisdom Apr 19, 2009 · Redguard isn't Ditra, they want you to use a good quality modified thinset over it. Waterproofing redgard vs ditra Had water overflow on bathroom. Because I have a background in tile and stone sales the owner has asked me to come up with some options for upgrades in our master baths as far as shower systems and waterproofing go. I then wa link to RedGard Uncoupling Mat Vs. You do need either 15# felt or 6 mil visqueen behind the durorock. I then used the Redgard tape for all seams and corners. Sep 21, 2018 · Dont use Redguard, its a krappy liquid sealer and is prone to leaks when installed incorrectly, If you want an absolute water proof membrane system look into Ditra or Prova, you will never be disappointed!!! Archives: Blog RedGard Uncoupling Mat Vs. I used a Kerdi pan and drain kit. Should I be using Ditra membrane under ceramic tiles in this case? Has anyone tried using a pool liner, or something fancier like schluter ditra underneath the durock? I know you can typically use a product like redgard over the top of durock, but I do not think the vinyl skim coat will adhere to redgard. It's got radiant heating in the slab. Cement Board: Which of the Two Should You Use? In reality, you’re probably better off using Schluter-Ditra in most circumstances, especially when water is involved. They describe it as providing isolation, uncoupling, and waterproofing, and say it meets "A118. Made of polyethylene, DITRA and DITRA-XL serve as a waterproofing layer that protects moisture-sensitive substrates, such as plywood/OSB. It is designed for tile installation projects on both commercial and residential properties. read the directions and limitations red guard isn't meant to span any real crack. Dec 29, 2015 · Which shower tile backer board is best? Cement board, Wedi board, Kerdi board, Hardibacker, Densshield, Durock, Permabase, or Wonder board Feb 13, 2009 · I'd never think of coating some drywall in red guard or any roll on product and think it'd be waterproof so I'd consider it an inferior product in that usage also. Both options have their pros and cons. Would it be possible to run the stove on the slab for this season and then tile the hearth without the Ditra in the summer? Jan 15, 2013 · The functioning of Schluter Ditra uncoupling membranes and other brands like Stratamat, Flexbone, Redgard, and Mapeguard. Ditra has four functions, uncoupling, load support, waterproofing and vapour management. Does anyone have any experience with it and could compare it with Schluter/Wedi/redguard? Seems much cheaper and very easy to work with. The last bathroom I did I decided not to use kerdi board due to a couple things I haven't liked about it - going back to cover the screws and it flexes, even after tile is installed. Ditra: Key Differences And Features RedGard Uncoupling Mat Vs. If you're going to tile outside I've always used ditra-drain Waterproofing these floors can save an owner from replacing the tile assembly and substructure in the event of a leak. Ditra is fantastic, and goes down easy. Why not contact the Gypcrete manufacturer (Maxxon) and let them prescibe alternatives to DITRA and Noble CIS? Oct 16, 2012 · I'm thinking Jaz meant that you can't put redguard on ditra because ditra has ruffles or ridges as pose to kerdi is flat. Ardex: X5, X77 Sep 9, 2022 · RedGard vs Cement Backer Board There are two methods one can use when installing tiles over plywood. The slab is in good shape with no cracks or high/low spots to be concerned about. In the main area, I cleaned the subfloor, used thinset to glue durock down, then screwed it off (yea, i should have used Ditra there but he didn't want to get to that yet). Tiling with 3x16 ceramic on Jun 15, 2023 · This article will take a look at what Redgard is, how it works, and how to use it. Under the slab we have two layers of XPS foam insulation and around the perimeter of the slab as well. Roast it before I tile it… Share Add a Comment Sort by: Best RedGard Uncoupling Mat Vs. Feb 23, 2007 · I would however use a sheet membrane like ditra or use cement board over the plywood, instead of redgard. 15 mortar and the products listed below meet this standard. But google isn't helping. A cement board is undeniably the Oct 14, 2011 · All times are GMT -6. The nicest thing about it is that it is a liquid-applied waterproofing membrane, which makes it perfect for tile installation. Doesn't look like they make pre-made nichesdoes anyone know if their product is compatible with Schluter Kerdi niches? For instance, Aquadefense is more flexible than Redgard, and it’s well-suited for areas that experience issues with hydrostatic pressure. Some significant differences are coming up, and in the end, you should be able to decide which one would be a better-suited choice for you. Although it is more expensive, the Redguard (paintable) is not a uncoupling membrane - AFAIK. I also think ditra is a far better isolation membrane than any rolled product. Jun 15, 2025 · Compare RedGard and Ditra uncoupling mats on installation, moisture management, and cost to find the best choice for your tile projects. So, I get the impression everyone loves Ditra, and common practice seems to be to use it everywhere, especially in floors. Uncoupling membranes There are tons of different uncoupling membrane options available on the market, and people often seem confused between two popular options, RedGard uncoupling mat vs. But I was going to do ditra, but home Depot dude said red guard. Uncoupling membranes Jan 2, 2022 · Most manufacturers, including Custom Redgard Uncoupling Mat and Laticrete Stratamat, will want you to use an ANSI 118. Here is the breakdown of my thinking. First time. Wanted to check if that was ok? My plan was to Redgard the whole floor before patching so the moisture from the patch/mortar doesn’t effect it and then cement backer over the entire floor once it’s level. My next shower. Uncoupling membranes Aug 8, 2022 · What is a Laticrete Strata Mat? The Strata Mat is an uncoupling membrane made by Laticrete. Nov 24, 2020 · If you are using Ditra, I don't really use a need for Redgard, unless your Ditra install is incredibly sloppy. I’m considering using Mapei Keraflex plus as it seems to be a decent product that can go over a membrane. The Strata facilitates Is one superior to the other? I think I’ve seen that Crack Isolation has an actual ANSI definition, but that Uncoupling doesn’t. Hi, we are planning to tile our basement floor, which is a concrete slab ~5" thick. I wouldn't recommend using modified over the redguard to put down ditra. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Ditra is made from Polyethylene plastic aka it can sit in a land fill for 100 years. Jan 24, 2021 · The schluter stuff is great, and all I've used since being out on my own. [1] Premixed Tile Mortar over Kerdi membrane Using any kind of premixed mastic over Schluter’s Kerdi membrane isn’t recommended. How hot, I'm not sure. Discover which membrane reigns supreme in "DITRA or STRATA - Which Membrane is Better?" Compare Schluter Systems & Laticrete underlayment products for your project. I hear Red Guard is considered a “crack isolation membrane”, but my contractor is suggesting a Ditra-like membrane. I did redgard over a mud bed pan for mine, and the ceiling, so a solid 5 sides of continuous waterproofing. I also want to use the Kerdi shower pan instead of messing with building a mortar pan. The latex or polymers in the thinset need to air dry to achieve maximum strength. DITRA provides uncoupling through its open rib structure, which allows for in-plane movement that effectively neutralizes the differential movement stresses between the substrate and the tile, thus eliminating the major cause of Oct 21, 2016 · Modified over redguard (unmodified over ditra - difference due to the fabric on redguard. Any opinions? Dec 23, 2020 · All times are GMT -6. Free-space on the underside of the matting provides a route for excess moisture and We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. But before you make a decision, you should know that Schluter is a kit that includes a tray and other components. With Ditra, is it necessary to have a plywood underlayment, or can I just install right over the floor as is (covering up the holes of course) and the thing will even itself out? Barring that, if I do need to install a underlayment, can I use 1/8 plywood? Apr 15, 2018 · Similar Threads Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post Ditra vs Redgard for floors Beowulf Tile Forum/Advice Board 5 04-28-2013 08:43 PM I didn't know redguard was considered a crack isolation membrane tbh. DITRA and DITRA-XL provide uncoupling to prevent cracked tile and grout. Oct 26, 2009 · Subfloor questions and Redguard vs Ditra Tile Forum/Advice Board It is not rotted though, the wood is sturdy. My house has a 3/4″ plywood subfloor with 16″ joist spacing so any of the Ditra options could work for me. Ditra products are great if you are looking for an all-in-one product for substrates to lay tile, but it's pricey. An easier way to do it would be to use a liquid applied membrane such as Redgard, AquaDefense, or Laticrete Hydro Ban. Jan 17, 2019 · Now I want to install ditra membrane over it and am not sure which thinset to use. It creates a waterproof membrane barrier and reduces crack transmission for use on both interior and exterior substrates. comSchluter-DITRA is a polyethylene membrane with a grid structure of square cavities, each cut back in a dovetail configuration, and an anchoring fleece laminated to the underside My plans are to remove a fiberglass shower enclosure and install a free standing soaking tub and re-tile the whole 60 sf bathroom floor space. Grind the paint off. I was planning on using hardibacker w/Kerdi but it seems that denseshield would save me some prepwork. I ended up forgetting the red guard. If the RedGard is applied properly in the required mil-thickness it won't be any less expensive than DITRA and certainly won't replace DITRA's attributes. That said, Aquadefense has more uses than Redgard, so it can be difficult to decide based on that alone. I'm going to use Ditra. He is recommending cement board so I don't have to re-spend as much on materials, but he says he does both regularly depending on the homeowner's preference. If you are looking to do a small tile job, stick with traditional methods of laying cement board and mortar. As you know, unmodified is recommended over Ditra, even when installing porcelain. In fact, this debate has stoked many of the conversations and threads on the tile and building forums for years. This tub got green board walls with sheets of kerdi over it, i felt like it went much faster that way. What I'm confused about is why unmodified thinset is used on ditra but it seems people use modified for shower walls? L Basically, I have white porcelain tile. With Ditra underneath and a ceramic or porcelain tile on top, the only way for the drying process to occur is for the moisture to evaporate through the grout joints which could take from 2 to I am building a custom shower and want to use Redgard for waterproofing. Uncoupling membranes Dec 17, 2005 · As far as the Ditra goes, use a modified thinset under the Ditra and an unmodified thinset over it when setting the tile. Then I checked the instructions on the premixed stone, porcelain and ceramic tile thin-set mortar which I am going Feb 18, 2021 · Rather than cement board or Ditra, how about liquid RedGard over a plywood subfloor before tiling? I understand the pros and cons of cement board and Ditra, but have never used RedGard. I am flood testing this shower on Monday. I would like to know what's everyone's preferred and possibly cost effective thin set to use with Schluter products. It not on top of ditra) Uncoupling Tile has been successfully installed for thousands of years by incorporating an uncoupling layer, or forgiving shear interface, within the tile assembly. Hi all. Home Depot has 54 sq ft rolls so you won’t have an absurd amount of waste. Shower walls to cover is about 80 sqft Redgard:- Supposedly easy to apply like rolling on paint- Need to tape and mud joints in cement board first- Some say you need way more than just 2 coats for waterproofing- Should also be primed with a waterdowned coat?- Cost about $220 for 3. #schluterditra #schlutersystems #schlutershowersystemsWhat is the difference between a crack isolation membrane and an uncoupling membrane like DITRA? This v Feb 16, 2022 · The Ditra-XL will provide additional support on large joist spacing or if you happen to have a really thin plywood subfloor (1/2″). [2] Schluter Jan 27, 2021 · We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Sep 21, 2012 · Compare Ditra to Redgard if you wanna, but you're comparing apples to orange juice. You’ll spend more time putting down cement board and covering with Kerdi membrane. One, you can use RedGard, preferably the uncoupling mat, to absorb the stress in the plywood and prevent it from spreading to the tiles. Hope this helps We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Ditra. For this reason, I’ve gone through the drawbacks and benefits of both products to compare and get a better idea before making a final decision… Jan 22, 2022 · Are you wondering about modified vs unmodified thinset mortars? Perhaps, you are thinking of installing a Ditra-Heat floor or a Schluter Kerdi Shower System? The internet is full of information and even misinformation on this very subject. If you’re a homeowner looking to save money on such a project, you might consider RedGard. xyml kzprvt lccm qsvkqgv oxreg crybul iur ddlcflfp wkp mutvlkn iquqfv shsyxgt pyguup muvlq sewfbk